Date: 23rd September 2007 at 6:25pm
Written by:

Scott Mathieson refereed Blackpool’s third 2-2 on the trot on Saturday, but what did our forum members make of his officiating?

Vital views and ratings:

‘I’ll give him a 3.5. Tried to, and actually succeeded in, playing the advantage well.’
SeasideEssexXile

‘2, should have had a penalty. Was a hand ball in the area.’
Crossy

‘1, and only because I have to.’
Platos

‘A bit picky for me but did ok, don’t think his assistants give him any help! 2.’
JCampbell

‘Penalty IMO but hard for the officials to see. 3 for the ref, 0.5 for the pisspoor assistant on the East stand side’
Jerry

The overall rating he received from all members was: 2.6 and places himself halfway up the leaderboard, and incidentally his score is exactly the same as last weeks referee, Mike Dean, whom had a mare at Old Trafford today!

PosName
P
Y
R
R
1K Hill
1
2
0
4.4
2A D’Urso
2
1
0
3.7
3A Talyor
1
0
0
3.55
4 G Sutton
1
1
0
3.5
5C Oliver
1
0
0
3.4
=E Iderton
1
0
0
3.4
7M Clattenburg
1
2
0
3.36
8M Russell
1
0
0
3.03
9S Mathieson
1
0
0
2.6
=M Dean
1
0
0
2.6
11K Wright
1
1
0
2.6
12A Marriner
2
2
0
2.2
13RJ Lewis
1
1
0
2.25
=R Olivier
2
5
0
2.25
15K Friend
1
3
0
2.21
16C Webster
1
1
0
2.1
17M Heywood
1
0
0
2
18Mark Halsey
1
0
0
1.9
19C Foy
1
3
0
1.75
=N Miller
1
0
0
1.75
21A Penn
1
2
0
1.5
=D Deadman
1
2
0
1.5
=L Probert
1
2
0
1.5
24S Bratt
1
4
0
1.3
25I Williamson
1
4
0
1.1
26T Kettle
1
2
0
1