Date: 18th December 2007 at 8:11pm
Written by:

A double bill, Eddie Ilderton (Tyne & Wear) who officiated the Cardiff game

4 – one of the better ones this season. Must’ve been alright as I hardly noticed him. Impressed with way he overruled his buffoon of an assistant! – sandgroanun

3 – as SGU said you hardly noticed him. Did miss a few things first half but not bad overall. Pity you couldnt say the same for the lino by the west stand. – Arksy

3.5 – and agreed hardly noticed him! – BispamTangerine

2- seemed reluctant to get a card out. After their goal for the next 76 minutes nothing but constant time wasting – free kicks taking forever, kicking the ball (& throwing it) away after the whistle had gone. 5 subs (before Evatt) so what does he play 4 minutes which equates to 1& 1/2 mins extra time. Not strong enough by far – hence the 2. – SeasideEssexXile

5! – A ref can’t get everything right, but he was close to doing so last night – Toronto_Pool

4 -Two good referee’s in a row, bloody hell fire -. bfcluck

2 -Smileyface – platos

2 -I thought he was poor. Too much time wasting. Pantomine with Schmeical and that other buffoon when they ‘argued’ about who was to take the free kick. Schmeical ‘gesturing’ to the North Stand. All went un-punished. If thats what Jack thinks is a 5… – crossy2425



So thanks to the big fat 5 from toronto Mr E Ilderton gets a 3.44 his old score was an equally impressive 3.4 so his new average is 3.42 keeping him at 4th in the table.



On Saturday we had the pleasure of Mr P Joslin in charge of the Stoke match.



1 – no comment – platos

2 – from me! – toronto_pool

1 –from me useless t**t – pickering_hat_trick

2.5 – Overall he wasn’t actually that bad, just a couple of times was annoying but on the whole wasn’t that bad.- bfcluke

3 – from me. I thought he was ok. Not really sure why he was booed off at the end. blobberman

2 from me.

1 – Too attention seeking for my like, and failed to show a red on 2 occasions. 1 when the guy should have been booked for assault on Morrell and 2, no 7’s 2 deliberate handballs after been booked first half. onefountain

1 – no comment – bispham_tangerine

1 – for turning up, not taking anything away from Stoke, the guy was poor, very poor. raging Bull

1 – The worst refferee so far by a country mile. How anyone that supports Blackpool can give him above 2 is beyond me. I would even go as far as to say he was biased. Perhaps it was repayment for his colleague cocking up at Preston? crossy2425 ** rounded up from .5

1 – Finnicky to say the least, once they got to him he was out of his depth. – SeasideEssexXile

1 – Every time the slightest bit of contact was made in the 2nd half, they got a freekick. One of the worst in a long, long time. IMO of course. Jerry

2 – Tried to stamp his authority and the game and failed miserably. He’s only saved a 1 because, yet again, we’ve had worse refs! AbelBFC

2 – from me. Not good and have seen a LOT worse this season. – sandgrown1

1.5 – because I can. And because he was s***e – BisphamTangerine

1 –rubbish – jcampbell

So Mr P Joslin scores a 1.5 bad but not the worst we`ve ever had. So the table now looks like…

PosName
P
Y
R
R
1K Hill
1
2
0
4.4
2A Talyor
1
0
0
3.55
3 G Sutton
1
1
0
3.5
4E Iderton
2
0
0
3.42
5A D’Urso
3
1
0
3.37
6M Clattenburg
4
2
0
3.30
7M Russell
1
0
0
3.03
8M Pike
1
1
0
3
9C Oliver
2
0
0
2.69
10C Foy
2
3
0
2.75
11S Mathieson
1
0
0
2.6
=M Dean
1
0
0
2.6
13K Wright
1
1
0
2.6
14A Marriner
2
2
0
2.2
15A Hall
1
2
0
2.3
16RJ Lewis
1
1
0
2.25
=R Olivier
2
5
0
2.25
17K Friend
1
3
0
2.21
18C Webster
1
1
0
2.1
19M Heywood
1
0
0
2
20Mark Halsey
1
0
0
1.9
=N Miller
1
0
0
1.75
22J Moss
1
1
0
1.72
23A Penn
1
2
0
1.5
=D Deadman
1
2
0
1.5
=L Probert
1
2
0
1.5
26P Joslin
1
1
0
1.5
27M Haywood
1
0
0
1.3
28G Laws
1
1
0
1.3
29S Bratt
1
4
0
1.3
30Mr Thorpe.
1
2
1
1.2
31I Williamson
1
4
0
1.2
32G Atkins
2
2
0
1,1
33T Kettle
1
2
0
1
34M Jones
1
3
0
1
35P Talyor
1
2
1
1